SkillProof tested Claude skills

Skill Share

Nur-Prosa-Skill-Gerüst, das über Rube an Slack postet; liefert keine Skripte

von frostant · frostant/awesome-claude-skills

Tested · Didn't pass

Skill Share — Nur-Prosa-Skill-Gerüst, das über Rube an Slack postet; liefert keine Skripte

Was es kann

Beschreibt einen workflow zum Erstellen eines Claude skill, validating its frontmatter, zipping it und announcing it to a Slack channel through the Rube MCP connector. In practice the folder contains a single markdown file — no creation, validation or packaging scripts exist, und die Slack half needs a Rube connection the skill does not help you set up. The same repository ships skill-creator, which does the creation, validation and packaging with real Python scripts.

Testbericht

Einen csv-cleaner skill angefordert, built and shared, both ways. Unassisted lieferte ich einen working skill — SKILL.md mit einer trigger-shaped description plus scripts/clean.py, das ich auf einer messy file ausführte und das die headers normalisierte und dropped 2 of 4 rows correctly. Following skill-share verbatim produced a two-line SKILL.md, three empty directories und a zip containing no logic at all, because the body never says to write any; strictly worse than doing it unassisted. Der Slack step, which is the skill's only original idea, ist unmeasured here — it calls Rube tool names (SLACK_SEND_MESSAGE, SLACK_FIND_CHANNELS) that need a connector and workspace OAuth this test could not reach. Its frontmatter also cites a LICENSE.txt that does not exist in the folder, though nine sibling skills in the same repo have one, and the repo's own skill-creator covers three of the four advertised features with actual Python scripts.

Getestet am: 2026-07-30 · Claude Code 2.x (agent harness)

Installation

git clone https://github.com/frostant/awesome-claude-skills.git
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cd awesome-claude-skills && cp -r skill-share ~/.claude/skills/skill-share

Befehle & Beispiel-Prompts

  • /skill-shareNur-Prosa-Skill-Gerüst, das über Rube an Slack postet; liefert keine Skripte

Skills reagieren auf normale Anfragen — keine Slash-Befehle nötig. Nach der Installation aktivieren Prompts wie diese den Skill (auf Englisch):

  • Help me package my csv-cleaner skill and post it to our Slack skills channel
  • Create a new Claude skill called csv-cleaner and validate its frontmatter
  • Build a skill scaffold, zip it, then announce it to the team via Rube

Vollständiger Testbericht (Englisch) →