SkillProof tested Claude skills

Skill Share

Prosa-kun færdigheds-scaffolder, der poster til Slack via Rube; leverer ingen scripts

Af frostant · frostant/awesome-claude-skills

Tested · Didn't pass

Skill Share — Prosa-kun færdigheds-scaffolder, der poster til Slack via Rube; leverer ingen scripts

Hvad det gør

Beskriver en workflow for at oprette en Claude skill, validere dens frontmatter, zippe den og annoncere den til en Slack channel through the Rube MCP connector. I praksis indeholder folderen en single markdown file — no creation, validation or packaging scripts exist, and the Slack half needs a Rube connection the skill does not help you set up. The same repository ships skill-creator, which does the creation, validation and packaging with real Python scripts.

Testrapport

Bad om en csv-cleaner skill, built and shared, both ways. Unassisted I shipped a working skill — SKILL.md with a trigger-shaped description plus scripts/clean.py, which I ran on a messy file and it normalized the headers and dropped 2 of 4 rows correctly. Following skill-share verbatim produced a two-line SKILL.md, three empty directories and a zip containing no logic at all, because the body never says to write any; strictly worse than doing it unassisted. The Slack step, which is the skill's only original idea, is unmeasured here — it calls Rube tool names (SLACK_SEND_MESSAGE, SLACK_FIND_CHANNELS) that need a connector and workspace OAuth this test could not reach. Its frontmatter also cites a LICENSE.txt that does not exist in the folder, though nine sibling skills in the same repo have one, and the repo's own skill-creator covers three of the four advertised features with actual Python scripts.

Testet: 2026-07-30 · Claude Code 2.x (agent harness)

Installation

git clone https://github.com/frostant/awesome-claude-skills.git
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cd awesome-claude-skills && cp -r skill-share ~/.claude/skills/skill-share

Kommandoer og eksempelprompter

  • /skill-shareProsa-kun færdigheds-scaffolder, der poster til Slack via Rube; leverer ingen scripts

Skills udløses af almindelige forespørgsler — ingen kommandoer at huske. Efter installationen aktiverer prompter som disse skillen (på engelsk):

  • Help me package my csv-cleaner skill and post it to our Slack skills channel
  • Create a new Claude skill called csv-cleaner and validate its frontmatter
  • Build a skill scaffold, zip it, then announce it to the team via Rube

Læs hele rapporten →